DW and I have stayed both on and off site.
Off site:
Hilton Gateway(doesn't exist any more)
Caravey Inn,gone also
Archway Inn,also gone now
on site:
Port Orleans,before the merge w/ Dixie
Carribean
All Star Movies
All Star Music

All in all,I really can't complain about any of them.For us ,a room is where we sleep,shower and keep our stuff.Don't need anything fancy or some amenities we never use anyway.