Quote Originally Posted by Lovin Disney
I just had a disgusting thought...

Maybe BEN was Jack's wife's lover. Ugh, wouldn't that be horrible?

That probably is too far-fetched. What am I talking about, this is Lost, anything is possible!
I saw that theory postulated on a message board. Just tried to find it now and I can't, but the poster had really thought it out and it kinda started to make sense. I really hope not though. Yucky.