Poly vs Contemporary

[Gibbs]

The Dw and I are in the midst of planning our trip for 2011. We have decided to step up to a deluxe resort this time We have narrowed the choices down to two. Now we need the help of our fellow intercotees to help make the final call. So, what say you? If you had your choice would it be the Poly or the Contemporary and why? We are looking foward to your hearing what you have to say.

[ibelieveindisneymagic]

I'd go for the Poly. The transportation can't be beat, since you can walk to the TTC. The smaller buildings are a plus for me, as is the lush landscaping (and watching Wishes from the beach).

Either way, you can't go wrong - enjoy!

[Donald's Girl]

No contest at all! Poly!!!

[forever a child]

I just think that the Poly is a beautiful resort! It would be my first Deluxe Resort choice

[mrsgaribaldi]

We've stayed at both. We even had a Magic Kingdom view at the Contemporary. We both loved the Poly more. I just love the grounds. Both are great but I would go to the Poly every time if I could.

[tmz814]

I'd go with the Poly. I've never stayed there myself but it's so beautiful.

[Goofy4TheWorld]

I just returned from my first stay at the Contemporary (and first Deluxe stay) and I would not vote for the Contemporary. The only transportation edge the CR has is the walk back home from MK at night. The Monorail wasn't as convenient as I thought it was going to be.

The CR has way too much of a business atmosphere (given it has the convention center) so the Poly is the only Monorail resort maybe left on my bucket list. I heard people on the bus talking about how they didn't like the people in suits and ties at the CR, and I agree. I felt silly standing in the elevator with a wet bathing suit while someone with their rolling briefcase and Blue-tooth in their ear was standing beside me talking about the 4pm conference on consolidation efficiencies.

Personal, I don't think either are worth the extra money, but between the two, I would pick Poly (even though I have only seen it from the bus stop since both resorts share buses, never actually stayed there.)

[jmj18]

The POLY everytime!

The people are so much nicer.....the atmosphere is so much nicer....

Just a WONDERFUL place!

Did not like the Contemporary at all!

[Mickey91]

I voted Poly but I honestly had a hard time deciding. The Poly is definitely more relaxing and the ambiance would be more romantic. The Contemporary, on the other hand, puts you right in the magic with Chef Mickey's and the monorail running through. It will be wonderful whichever you choose!

[KAT1811]

Simply put the decor of the CR does not appeal to me at all.

[CU Tiger]

The Poly is not as noisy, more lush, better pool area, ... I can go on. Pick Poly .

[Ksmith75]

i would say the poly. we have never stayed at either, but have done meals and the pirates and pal fireworks voyage from the CR and meals at the poly. We went a little early to the CR to look around, and didnt really like it at all. It seemed cold...and not very attractive. The poly is nicely themed and beautiful....we go early there too, just to look around and sit in the lobby!

[DizNee143]

Contemporary!!!!!!!!!
LOVE it there!

[Tigerinvestigator]

Stayed at both resorts many times. Spent my honeymoon at the Contemporary.....but only because the Poly was full! LOL Can't really go wrong with either but the Polynesian is without a doubt my favorite resort at WDW!

[diz_girl]

While the CR is special to me because I stayed there the most growing up, I really prefer the Poly. I just love the smell of the lobby, as well as the lush, tropical feel of the lobby and the resort as a whole. Watching Wishes and the EWP from the beach is great too. Then there's the Volcano pool, which kids love. And the restaurants are also great. I really like Captain Cook's, which is the counter service restaurant. You can get Tonga Toast for breakfast and stir fry for dinner. Plus, the transportation is key. It's nice to have two monorail lines within a short walk. We never waited long a for a bus to DHS or AK.

[SBETigg]

I think Poly will be the resort of choice, in general, but they both have a lot going for them and you won't make a wrong choice with either of them. So much depends on your own preferences. I've stayed in both and I prefer the Polynesian for the lush, exotic, relaxed feel. The Contemporary always feels a little sterile, cavernous, and business-like to me. But great rooms, spacious and neat, and the views are amazing on both sides.

[4disneynuts]

We just booked the Poly for December (our first stay at a deluxe resort). We are very excited. We got a theme park room and are looking forward to switting on our balcony and watching the fireworks over Magic Kingdom. I have wanted to stay at Poly since I was a little girl (dreams really do come true).

I think it depends on your personality which you choose. We chose Poly for the relaxed tropical feel. We usually stay at CBR and love it there. Have a great trip no matter which you choose!!!ALOHA.

[DisneyorBust]

I am a confirmed [B]Poly[B] fan. I choose the Poly due to the overall feel of the resort, it is a 'get away' just in itself. Many positives, landscaping, large rooms, views of the Magic Kingdom, fireworks, and Polynesian music playing in the background.
I have to agree with SBETigg; I found the Contemporary to be sterile and business like also.
The Poly represents relaxation to me, almost a destination in itself.

[awaggett]

We have stayed in both--and loved both. However, I prefer the Contemporary. I think the rooms are brighter, more updated, and basically, more my taste. I also love the feel/excitement of the 4th floor--shops,restaurant, etc.

[Marymouse2003]

I know ppl on Intercot LOVE Poly, but my heart belong to CR.....love the feeling of being in 1 bldg....not to mention Chef Mickey going on all the time AND the view of MK just takes my breath away, but this is just me.....either way, you will have awesome time. Enjoy