|
|
|
View Poll Results: POTC or HM?
- Voters
- 120. You may not vote on this poll
-
Haunted Mansion
-
Pirates of the Caribbean
-
 Disney Mania Question #10
Today we are spending the day (imaginatively of course) at the Magic Kingdom and we (that being all of us) need to pick a ride to go on 10 times in a row. We will ride, get off, and then immediately board again, 10 times in a row. Now I know many of us love Pirates of the Caribbean and the Haunted Mansion but given the repetative riding which would you choose?
I hope everyone has a great weekend. At some point this weekend I will be posting a recap of the first 5 Disney Mania Questions in the Mousellaneous forum of Intercot. Disney Mania Question #11 will appear Monday in the Dining forum of Intercot.
"All your dreams can come true if you have the courage to pursue them." - Walt Disney
"Too many people grow up. That 's the trouble with the world, too many people grow up." - Walt Disney
-
Please Support INTERCOT's Sponsors:
-
Man, I love both, but I'd pick HM. There is always something on that ride i didn't catch before.
July '78 - Offsite
Aug '94 - Offsite
Nov '96 - Offsite (honeymoon)
Nov '97 - CBR (2nd honeymoon)
Jul '04 - Offsite (DS & oldest DD B-day)
Nov '08 - POR (youngest DD b-day & 12th aniv.)
-
Wow I thought I would be going against the norm in this poll. Boy was I wrong. I'm not a big Pirates fan. It was an okay ride- but the mansion is just incredible.
-
Haunted Mansion! Would be especially great if it were October 
-
HM, it's the one ride I remembered from my first trip in the 70's
74 Off Site
98 Contemporary & DCL inaugural cruise
99 Dixie Landings
00 Dixie Landings
01 POR & DCL
02 AKL & DCL
03 VB
04 DL GC
05 ASSp, VWL, GF
06 POFQ, CSR, OKW
07 ASMo & VWL
08 Pop VWL
09 BW, POR, VWL, CSR
10 WL
12 VWL, AKL Club
13 VWL, WL Club
-
I'd go with the Mansion...always something new to see, I never am able to take it all in!
Heather aka ibelieveindisneymagic
INTERCOT Staff
Engaged at the castle!
My Disney Home is POFQ
-
I'm going with Haunted Mandion. I love this ride and like everyone has said, there's always something new to see.
º0º Kelli º0º
01/19/2007-Pop Century
12/14/2008-All Star Movies
06/27/2009-All Star Sports
05/08/2010-All-Star Movies
06/17/2011-All Star Movies
07/09/2014-All Star Movies - Anniversary
06/06/2019-Art of Animation - Son's Graduation Trip
-
Wow, I'm really surprised that the Mansion is doing so well. It's great, don't get me wrong, but for me, Pirates is that much better and bears repeating over and over again.
Sherri
Next: Aulani Celebration 10/2018 (50th)
Past Stays: Contemporary, GF, Poly, BC, POP, POR, Dolphin, AKL Kidani, BLT
1990 August Honeymoon- GF
Delighted Disney Return Guest since 1981, DVC (BLT) since 2014
-
For me it would be Haunted Mansion.
-
I went with HM. If the POTC was DL then I would have picked it. It is better than WDW POTC.
LIZ
Disneyland-Too many times to count
WDW
APRIL 2005 - Offsite
DECEMBER 2006 - Fort Wilderness
OCTOBER 2007-Saratoga Springs Resort
SEPTEMBER 2009-OKW
-
-
 I have to agree with most of the posters...I went with HM...there is just wayyyy too much going on to catch eeverything. I still see things I know I missed before!
~*~Tonya~*~
1st = 1992
ASMo = Jan. 6-12 '07
POP = Jan 5-11 '08
BWV = Jan 6-16 '09
BCV = Jan 12-22 '10
BWV = Jan. 21-29 '11
BWV = Jan. 21-28 '12
BWV = Dec. 8-15 '12
BCV/BWV=Jan. 24-Feb. 1 '14
BWV = Jan. 16-24 '15
BWV = Jan. 29-Feb. 6 '16
BWV = Jan. 20-28 '17
BWV = Jan. 26-Feb. 3 '18
-
My all time favorite ride is POTC but I agree that there is so much to see at HM that you would find something new with each ride. HM gets my vote.
Feb '19 Aulani
Aug '18 Pop Century
Feb '18 Disneyland
Dec '16 Yacht & Beach Club
Oct '13 Carribbean Beach
Dec '10 AK Kidani Village
Dec '09 Port Orleans FQ
Dec '08 Polynesian
Dec '05 Pop Century
Dec '02 AS Sports
'73- '92 numerous off site
'71 Disneyland
-
Haunted Mansion for me! It's so homey!
Jul80 DLR, Dec75 FW, Sept91 offsite, Sept95 ASSp, June00 offsite, June01 ASMo, July02 WL, June03 ASMo, Oct03 POR, Poly, Aug04 Pop,ASMu, Oct04 ASSp, Sept05 CSR,Pop,CBR, Dec06 WL,Pop, Sept07 POP,POR, Dec07 POP,May08 POP, Sept08 CR,Sept09 POP,Aug10 CBR, Feb11 POP, July11 AKL, Nov12 POP, March13 offsite
-
I love both of them and it was hard to choose.
I love the Mansion even more since the update.
Also the update at POTC is great. 
[COLOR="Red"][/COLOR BEEN THERE, DONE
THAT AND GOING BACK IN 18 DAYs!!!º0º
-
I voted for the Haunted Mansion its always good fun
---------------------------------------------------------
Offsite 1996 to 2005
Dec 2006 2007 2008 CBR
Dec 2009 2010 2011 2013 2014 2017 BLT
Dec 2012 2015 2016 2018 OKW
Dec 2017 2018 S/S
June 2010 BCV
June 2012 OKW
-
This one was HARD. I love them equally and look at them as both in forst place
Countless Disneyland trips
May 2000 Honeymoon 1st DW Trip
April 2001 AS Music
May 2003 Off-site
December 2003 AS Movies
July 2004 Disneyland
December 2005 AS Movies
September 2007 Pop
March 2009 Pop
Christmas 2010 Movies
June 2011 off-site
Christmas 2012 Caribbean Beach
-
I have to abstain,I love them both the same.We always start out every trip with a visit to POC first and end the trip with HM,with a couple stops in the middle of course
1981(FW) 1982(FW) 1983(FW) 1984(FW) 1985(FW)
1986(FW) 1987(FW) 1989-2x(FW) 2004(ASMO)2008(CSR)
You can't just let it go...not even on your birthday.
-
 Originally Posted by SBETigg
Wow, I'm really surprised that the Mansion is doing so well. It's great, don't get me wrong, but for me, Pirates is that much better and bears repeating over and over again.
I understand what you're saying. I agonized over this one because Pirates is well done. But HM has more things in it. If I had to ride something 10 times in a row I'd go for the greater number of differences but honestly, I wouldn't want to overdo either of them. Don't want to risk feeling I've done them enough.
26 years staying at the Polynesian
There's a great big beautiful tomorrow, shining at the end of everyday...
Twenty six straight years staying at the Polynesian
Next trip: October 2018
-
too hard
This is like picking between children! Can't even do it!
Share This Thread On Social Media:
Share This Thread On Social Media:
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Reply With Quote
Share This Thread On Social Media: