Survivor: Micronesia - Fans vs. Favorites

[NotaGeek]

Here it is folks!

From Reality Blurred.com:

Survivor’s second all-star season is currently being filmed in Palau, the location for the show’s 10th season, according to reports.
Production started Monday, and Palau’s 10th season “locations will reprise their roles for Tribal Camps, Tribal Council, Challenges, Production Facilities, Loser Lodge, and the Ponderosa,” according to Survivor Maps.
TV Squad runs down the rumored participants for the second all-star edition, which will feature only contestants from seasons nine to 15. One rumored contestant is Julie Berry, which is suspicious because she is dating Jeff Probst.

[Melanie]

Nooooo. Really? Hmmmm.

[pixiesmimi]

Man! I'm really getting tired of these replays of the reality shows aka All Stars. Come up with some new ideas or take it off. It really gets old when you see the same people on everything.

I'm surprised they are already filming the next show when this one isn't off yet. How does Jeff show up in two different places? Oh, yeah. This one is prerecorded. Duh!

[Ian]

I know it's not the most popular opinion, but I actually really like the All Star editions.

My biggest problem with most reality shows is that it takes me 10 weeks to develop a serious rooting interest in someone.

With All Stars, it's much less, because I already know them.

[murphy1]

Here is a list of who they are possibly having, it could change. Most of you might remember I am friends with Parvati's family, so that was cool for her to possibly be asked back, but we kind of knew. I love Ozzy, I thought he would win, it would be fun to see him in the challenges again:

Survivor 9: Vanuatu Eliza Orlins who placed 4th
Julie Berry who placed 5th (and Jeff Probst's girlfriend)
Ami Cusack who placed 6th
Survivor 10: Palau Katie Gallagher who placed 2nd
Ian Rosenberger who placed 3rd
Jenn Lyon who placed 4th
Coby Archa who placed 9th
Survivor 11: Guatemala Lydia Morales who placed 4th
Judd Sergeant who placed 6th
Gary Hogeboom who placed 7th
Survivor 12: Panama Terry Deitz who placed 3rd
Cirie Fields who placed 4th
Shane Powers who placed 5th
Survivor 13: Cook Islands Ozzy Lusth who placed 2nd
Parvati Shallow who placed 6th
Jonathan Penner who placed 7th
Survivor 14:Fiji Yau-Man Chan who placed 4th
Michelle YI who placed 10th
Survivor 15:China Courtney
James

[Ian]

Hmmm ... I could do without seeing Shane again ...

I'm shocked he'd leave his son again after all the hysterics last time.

[offwego]

And courtney seems like an odd choice too.

But I agree with Ian I kinda like the all-star ones (in particular with Survivor where the type of person is so important!)

[TheDuckRocks]

If this is a true list I'd love to see Yau-Man or Ozzie win it. It's also nice to see no winners on the list.

[thrillme]

Bummer on Courtney. I haven't gotten past wanting to slap the dickens out of her THIS season. If I never see that little.... it will be too soon...

However I'm going to LOVE seeing Yao Mon and Ozzy.

[KarenP]

Hmmm ... I could do without seeing Shane again ...

I'm shocked he'd leave his son again after all the hysterics last time.

I'm with you on this! He really creeped me out when he was on before. Not looking forward to hearing him whine again either.

[pixiesmimi]

Ewww! Shane! I had enough of him the last time! Can't believer they didn't vote him off sooner. I guess from this list that neither James nor Courtney win this episode. Maybe this should have been posted as a spoiler??? I was hoping James would win right now. I may change my mind later but I have been rooting for him so far.

[d_m_n_n]

I know it's not the most popular opinion, but I actually really like the All Star editions.

My biggest problem with most reality shows is that it takes me 10 weeks to develop a serious rooting interest in someone.

With All Stars, it's much less, because I already know them.

I like the All-Stars too for the same reason. Sometimes I think it makes the game more interesting when everybody has seen how the other competitors play. That influences alliances and votes (remember Richard Hatch "I've been bamboozled" ).

I didn't start watching China (my TIVO can only handle so much ), but will definitely pick up the All Stars. Glad to see Yau-man, Michelle and Ozzie back.

[Disneypixie513]

Cool! I'd love to Ozzy and Yau-man again! I really hope they don't bring back Courtney..I can't stand her this season..She's a skinny,whiney brat..Geez..Half of these people i don't even remember :-/

[Bethis26fan]

I'm with you on this! He really creeped me out when he was on before. Not looking forward to hearing him whine again either.

add me to that list too, ugh lol

[Ian]

And courtney seems like an odd choice too.

I wonder what that means in terms of how well she does or doesn't do this season? Seems like there are no winners on the list, so ....

If this is a true list I'd love to see Yau-Man or Ozzie win it.

Agreed. I really liked both of them.

I'm with you on this! He really creeped me out when he was on before. Not looking forward to hearing him whine again either.

He totally reminds me of DW's friend's loser husband. Everytime he came on the screen I wanted to belt him in the mouth!

[Momof2boys]

Although some names sound familiar, I'm lost as to who some of them are. I agree with Ian about already knowing everyone and being able to root for (or against) someone early on because we know them better.

[bleukarma]

I enjoyed the last All Stars, but I think I’ve only seen 1 season between season 9 and 15 (but I’m watching China now). I don’t remember the season I watched, so everybody will be new to me. If I remember correctly, the first All Stars had a millionaire in it so there is still hope for James or Courtney. It will be hard for me watch Courtney some more though!!!

[SBETigg]

I've seen the revised supposed list for the Fans and Favorites show and it features ten past players only, with a team of newcomers to the game going up against them. Some of the people on Shari's list will be there but others won't, and some people who weren't named will be taking part. It could be that the list I saw was wrong, too.

[TheDuckRocks]

I've seen the revised supposed list for the Fans and Favorites show and it features ten past players only, with a team of newcomers to the game going up against them. Some of the people on Shari's list will be there but others won't, and some people who weren't named will be taking part. It could be that the list I saw was wrong, too.

Sherri, could you post what you have seen? I promise I won't hold you to it if it's wrong.

[SBETigg]

I don't want to spoil it for people who don't want to know. I'll PM you, Kay. If anyone else wants to know, PM me and I'll tell you what I saw.