NEW THREAD STARTED, WITH SPOILERS. Harry Potter VII [Merged Threads]

[pshokie]

What spoiler? A few pages back we were mostly discussing theories, some we got right, some wrong....

Correction. Some you got right, most I got wrong!

And could we please not talk about "the walk".....oh great. There I go again....

[dixielandings]

Edited to add: I forgot to quote the correct post to which I am replying. It obviously had to do with the spoiler I mentioned.

It was short and not written by one of the many theorists (you all are amazing by the way - I would have driven myself crazy - I just immersed myself in re-reading the series to gear up for DH). Anyway, it was a spoiler regarding Snape. Should I go find it and PM someone? I don't want to draw any unnecessary attention to it, especially most people seemed to miss it.

[Speedy1998]

I was visiting a Harry Potter Discussion board to see what peoples reactions to the seventh book were. There was one person who was ranting that they hated the book, and they finished their rant with this statement "Does she just make it up as she goes along?"

[krose78]

Don't they know this is all true? You couldn't just make this stuff up.

[pshokie]

Don't they know this is all true? You couldn't just make this stuff up.

Of course it's all true. How else can you explain everything Harry does in the movies?

[MsMin]

I finished the book last night. I had been so busy I didn't get a chance to read and since I was off today I ended up staying up to finish it(5:30am). I do think that there were some points I made that no one commented on that were very very close. I won't elaborate until our 10 days and please don't go back and read them if you're not finished.
My current opinion of the book:
I was satisfied with the outcome and it was done well IMO.More comments later.

[TigChatt]

I finished the book last night. I had been so busy I didn't get a chance to read and since I was off today I ended up staying up to finish it(5:30am). I do think that there were some points I made that no one commented on that were very very close. I won't elaborate until our 10 days and please don't go back and read them if you're not finished.

I think that we can discuss it now, because JKR has discussed it in interviews herself

[Jeff]

I think that we can discuss it now, because JKR has discussed it in interviews herself

Good point. Let's check with the moderators of this tread.

[jedigrrrl]

I don't get the 10 day thing either. If you haven't read the book, why would you be in rooms where people are discussing it? I did not turn on the computer, TV, radio, NOTHING until I was finished. But whatever.... we wait...

[conorsmom2000]

I don't get the 10 day thing either. If you haven't read the book, why would you be in rooms where people are discussing it? I did not turn on the computer, TV, radio, NOTHING until I was finished. But whatever.... we wait...

Partly it's because this thread was started as a discussion about the book, prior to the book coming out - so, it was about guesses, questions, theories, etc. Someone who took part in the thread at the beginning may not have finished the book yet, and wouldn't be expecting to find spoilers in here - once we start talking about it, though, obviously there will be. We just didn't want to ruin it for anyone.

But, to quote Harry in Book 7 "is this the moment"? Personally, my feelings are it's been a week - any die hard fan has read the book by now (um, some of us twice already ) so I think the ban can be lifted! Thoughts?

[TigChatt]

I'm game if the moderators approve!

[PirateLover]

Yea I think it's time.
I'll be the first...
In the end, it turns out Harry Potter is.....
BATMAN!!!!!!!!!

Seriously though, I'm ready to start chatting about Harry here on good ol Intercot.

[ncscgirl2005]

Yea I think it's time.
I'll be the first...
In the end, it turns out Harry Potter is.....
BATMAN!!!!!!!!!

Seriously though, I'm ready to start chatting about Harry here on good ol Intercot.

Same here!

[krose78]

Ok its been nine days and if I don't talk about it soon I think I am going to or i've been Can't we start now were only one day early.

[dixielandings]

Ok its been nine days and if I don't talk about it soon I think I am going to or i've been Can't we start now were only one day early.

Ditto here! No one I know has finished so I'm dying to talk! I'm begging DH to read the series but he's insisting on going straight to book 6 and "catching up" later. Whatever.

[drummerboy]

MODERATOR ALERT

I am going to lock this thread and start a new one with a spoiler warning for those who have already read the newest HP. Please go to the new thread for discussion of the book.

Thank you.