~ Have only made the playoffs 10 times in the 40 years since.

Pagan I know you are baiting Gueli, but the above quote is all the explanation needed. A 25% playoff appearence record would be a dream come true for a number NFL fans. Thats six more playoff runs than the Cards, 9 more than the Lions, and 9 more than the current incarnation of the Browns. Over those same years the other three NFL tyeams on the list's win loss records make the Jets look like Lombardi's Packers. I think you actually made the case yourself against inclusion.

If I could have a redo I probably would pull Golden State and include the Maple Leafs, Bengals, or Pirates. I would love to include the Jaguars due to their horrible fan base but they have been pretty consistintly average, not horrible on the field.