Holy cow! Congrats on a fantastic opportunity!

I would definitely stay at the Poly if I had an option...laid back, beautiful, romantic...and on the monorail line! Can't beat watching the fireworks on the beach for a romantic moment to make your DW swoon

BUT, it largely depends on your style/likes. If you're more formal and elegant go GF. It's beautiful and very reminiscent of a by-gone era. If you love adventure and travel (and animals), try AKL. If you want the best the "tropics" have to offer, go Boardwalk....

Whichever you choose, you can't lose. It's a win-win situation, they're all beautiful and extravagant accomodations.

And I wouldn't worry about Pop Warner. Even if you run into it, it won't ruin your trip. You'll just have brief irritating moments!