Star Tours 3D vs. Toy Story Mania vs. Soarin'

[Lightning McQueen]

Rank the big 3 screen rides in order from best to worst (For those who have ridden all three).

[MickeysBestPal]

Since they are not similar in most regards, I consider their strengths to be in different areas.

It would not be unusual to like all three.

Similar to having three children.
They are different, to be sure, and rating them
"in order" does not seem necessary.

[micky95]

My first choice is Soarin,very relaxing & love the orange scent.next Toy story Mania,love the arcade games & a little fun competition with my DW.last Star Tours, i love the total immersion with the 3D & movement but it makes me a little quessy.looking forward to the new Star Tours.

[crmark1]

I have only rode Sorin but will be trying the other two in only 32 more days! Cant wait!

[Ms. Mode]

1. Soarin'
2. Toy Story Mania
3. Star Tours (last only until I ride the new verson, I really like the idea of 50 different sequences)

[MississippiDisneyFreak]

1. Soarin
2. Toy Story Mania
3. Star Tours

[lovinmesomedisney]

1. Definitely SOARIN

2. Toy Story Mania

3. Star Tours.....really no comparison to the others. I'll have to judge after I get to ride the new version.