Pop or All Stars for 1 night?

[emerzmom]

I am traveling to Tampa for a wedding in a few weeks and decided to go a day early to WDW...maybe MVMCP too. It is the day after my birthday so it is a little birthday present to my self. :birthday:
I am going to most likely be traveling alone. Since this is just 1 night and I will be going to at least 1 park I did not think it would be worth the extra $$ to stay at anything above Pop or All Stars. I have never been to Pop and went to All Stars once. I was not overly thrilled with All Stars but it was okay. How is Pop? I know some really love it. I was thinking about giving it a try. Any thoughts?
What would you do for 1 night stay at WDW???
:tink:
Julie

[Middle of the Map]

Pop vs. All Stars? I would go with Pop for just one night. Which park are you planning on visiting?

Oh, and Happy Birthday to You!

[JoDisney]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY! I would go with Pop. Get a room on inside of resort.

[1DisneyNut]

I would try POP. I have never tried it but we did stay in All Star Music once and All Star Sports once and hated both with a passion. POP has to be better from reading posts around here.

[GAN]

I can't speak for All-Stars, but I've stayed at Pop for several 1/2 night stays and have no complaints at all.

[Pirate Granny]

Pop was our resort of choice before we bought our DVC. Although I'm told it is now considered a "premium" value, Higher priced then the all stars.

[Arielfan98]

Pop is more money than All Stars. I would normally recommend All Star Music or Movies, but it seems for your situation Pop is the best. Enjoy and have a great Birthday.

[Middle of the Map]

Oh, I just found the answer to my own question in your post. Duh.... I was temporarily dazzled by all that pixie dust.

Have a great Birthday at Magic Kingdom. What a fabulous place to be on your special day.

[emerzmom]

Thanks for the thoughts on this. I think I will give Pop a try. I doubt it will become my favorite resort but it might be fun!
Thanks!
:tink:
Julie

[brownie]

If you're not interested in staying at an All-Star resort, stay at Pop Century.

[EJS-Houston]

I've stayed at All-Star Sports many times, and Pop only once...but I honestly greatly prefer Pop.

[JerseyDad]

...even though POP is a higher "tier" ...I'd stay there for the theming and the dedicated buses.

....no need to get a "top price preferred location" room (pool view or poolside) ....but a preferred location in maybe the 50's buildings would be nice ...and quiet ...and close to the food, buses, and bar.

[#1donaldfan]

POP over All Stars any day of the week !! When taking my CM, DD down to seasonally work we typically stay a night or two at a value and I've been to both and find POP far and above better than any of the All Star ones......:thumbsup:

[Crow]

POP ive stayed at more than AS. and you can walk to AOA. its also more centrally located

[MississippiDisneyFreak]

My personal preference is All Stars