American Idol Experience - Now Testing - Review

[John]

Just a quick note that the American Idol attraction at Disney's Hollywoood Studios is now doing sneak previews.

We were at the 10am show today and got to see three performers do their thing during the run thru.

From what I could tell, 1 was legitimate and 2 were plants - most likely just for testing purposes - but who knows - maybe backups or a backup concept in case they don't get enough good contestants for a given show or if they need someone for "simon" to be mean to.

We waited outside for about 15-20 minutes before proceeding inside. During that time, there was a crowd warmup where they shot some video used later in the show supporting one of the contestants and a run thru on the background of the attraction from Ryan Seacrest on the overhead monitors.

Inside, the theatre looked newly refurbished. Brand new seats with "vote enabled" armrests. The stage itself was very attractive and mimicked the real idol stage. I especially liked what appeared to be a high def jumbotron display built into the arch behind the performers. This display enabled in show video and graphics.

The warm up announcer came out to explain the goings on and get the crowd psyched about 10 minutes prior to showtime.

Then the lights went down and the "show" began with the substitute Ryan coming out with the typical idol open. He gave the details of the show and introduced the judges. A gentlemen made to be a randy clone, a paula type clone (both had different names) and a dude named simon (right) who was from the UK. Shocker.

From there we were introduced to the contestants - and then the performing began.

Up first, a gentleman who appeared to be legit and had a bunch of family in the audience. He did rather well.

Second, a perky girl who was a "stunt person" - who they coincedentally had backstage footage of during her audition process - problem is her hair looked different and it was suspicious they had more material for her than the rest of the contestants. Her performance was not bad. It was almost as though she didn't hit the high notes right on purpose though.

Finaly, a worker from disney who supposedly came over on their lunch break... uh - yeah. She was good - but not too good.

The judges liked the guy, and mostly liked 2 and 3 but threw in some suggestions - and of course, simon threw in some zingers.

It was then time to vote. They showed reviews of the perfomances and you cast your vote on a keypad built into the armrest.

Then, they announced the winner which in this case was the guy #1.

From there - (and I hope I got the order right) there was a Jordan Sparks video that you were supposed to sing along with and get up and dance. Very, very hokey at that point. Quite forced and I don't see many audiences getting into it to the degree I think they'd like you to. We'll see.

Anyway, as it was a trial, I'm not suggesting that I think there will be plants every show since I would imagine they won't have problems finding hams in the DHS crowds every day - but it is something to look out for. I am hoping they keep it honest in that sense.

The show was actually entertaining - and I can see it getting better as it rolls along. The production values were very good and it did remind you of watching the show on tv. We as a family had a good time.

On the needs work front - I really could do without the clone judges. The simon was just to smarmy and the randy was just too "YO DOG!" for me. The Paula clone was fine though her outfit was a little over the top. Grade A performance goes however to the announcer - he was pretty dead on and did a very nice job. Honestly, I think it almost would have been better to have just wiped the slate and put in three judges who weren't trying to be like the existing judges.

Overall, I think this attraction will be a winner and a nice addition to a tv/movie theme park. It will be interesting to see how the auditioning goes and what kind of talent they get when things get rolling for real.

I've posted video of the preshow and the stage on our Idol page... you can find it here:

INTERCOT's American Idol Expereince Page (http://www.intercot.com/themeparks/disneystudios/echolake/americanidol/default.asp)

[The Joker]

The "Simon" judge's name probably was really...Simon! My guess is, it was Simon Needham, ex AC castmember and originating from the UK. He is supposed to be one of the judges on AIE. He is also known as one of the Jedi knight trainers during Star Wars weekends. If you Google him you'll get his picture from several other sites.

[John]

The "Simon" judge's name probably was really...Simon! My guess is, it was Simon Needham, ex AC castmember and originating from the UK. He is supposed to be one of the judges on AIE. He is also known as one of the Jedi knight trainers during Star Wars weekends. If you Google him you'll get his picture from several other sites.

The pictures I found using google did not match the person that was the "simon in the show - unless his name is spelled wrong or something. I should have written down the stage names but was trying my best to be "on vacation" ;)

[mouseketeer mom]

How long are you in this attraction?? Sounds like a long time to me..how do they work the flow of guests?

[John]

About 20 minutes and from what I could tell, they were running shows on the hour starting at 12 noon.

[The Joker]

The pictures I found using google did not match the person that was the "simon in the show - unless his name is spelled wrong or something. I should have written down the stage names but was trying my best to be "on vacation" ;)

I checked Google and found that another Simon Needham pops up; I was referring to a pic on mouseplanet, in an article about the AC. Did you check that?

[John]

Yes, it looks similar to him - so it probably is. Nice that he got recycled to another attraction after the adventurers club - though I am not sure what qualifies him to be a judge. Maybe he has some good credentials - or he just "fits the part".

He's got his har slicked back and I believe glasses on - and had the shirt unbuttoned thing going - it was a little over the top for me.

[JPL]

John
Not being a Fan of the show would a non-fan enjoy the experience? I mean of course I will try and experience at least once since I give everything a try at WDW. But curious how you think the show will play to those of us who are not fans of the show.

[Imagineer1981]

Harry Potter world is coming to Universal, and this is the best they could compete with?

[Stu29573]

I can't say that this is of much interest to me. I'm one of about two people on the planet who have never seen the show and don't care to. Oh well... :D

[John]

John
Not being a Fan of the show would a non-fan enjoy the experience? I mean of course I will try and experience at least once since I give everything a try at WDW. But curious how you think the show will play to those of us who are not fans of the show.

It's entertainment. I can see that if you get real folks coming into the theme parks, it will be pretty cool to see them competing. It's a live show - so you are either into that sort of thing or you arent. I can see it as a pretty nice way to spend some time indoors in the summer fun. Idol fans will love it - others will be amused and the disney diehards will complain just like they have already started to in this thread ;)

Seriously though, it's a nice tie in, in a movie/tv related park that fills a theatre that was dark with one of the most popular franchises in TV in a long time. Sounds like a winner, provided they tweak it a little. Now they just need to find something to fill the Drew Carey theatre... ugh.

Now as far as this being an Eticket, it's not - nor is it meant to compete with the likes of a whole new land at universal. I along with all of you would love to see an Indy ride or something at the studios... but I digress.

It is what it is - and it's welcome in mho.

[Goes4FastPass]

I'm not an Idol worshipper either. Why does this sound like another cruise ship karaoke show?

[John]

I'm not an Idol worshipper either. Why does this sound like another cruise ship karaoke show?

Honestly, I think there is a certain element of that with much higher production values and screening going on.

[Miss Tink 2]

John,
How do you audition for this? We are going to be there in May and my daughter and her husband would love to try to get on!!!
Luanne

[Aurora]

Thanks for the review John.

From what you said, I'm betting there will be enough combinations of 1. fans of the show who always wanted to be in it, 2. local people who audition, and 3. people who make a special trip just so they can audition, to make this a very popular attraction for awhile.

I haven't told my daughter about it because she is a HUGE AI fan and she'd be needling me 10 times a day about when our next trip will be (which we don't know yet).

I'm looking forward to seeing it.

[John]

I believe this is how it works...

Auditions start at park opening and are held in a separate line around the back of the attraction.

first show time is at noon and a final show later in the day puts all the days winners up against each other.

the winner gets a pass to the front of the line at a real american idol audition. From there, there are no guarantees ...

[DizneyFreak2002]

Harry Potter world is coming to Universal, and this is the best they could compete with?

This is not Disney's answer to HP, have no fear... Monster's Inc roller coaster is right around the corner as are other projects.... Disney is taking the right approach with HP, wait and see..

As for AIE, I am not a fan of the show, but, I may check this out... At least it gives us something else to do in a park that is not flowing with too many must sees..

[GrumpyFan]

Sounds like it will be fun to see an audition show, and a finale, at least once, not sure about how much more than that. I'm wondering how they're going to handle the finale crowds, especially on nights when they're not showing Fantasmic. I know they have the big screen out front to show it (supposedly), but will people hang around for it? Will they be satisfied with not being able to get in for the finale? Makes me wonder too, if they'll give a fastpass or front of line pass to family members of the finalists.

[Maleficent's Dad]

John,
Thanks for the review - as a skeptic since the announcement of this attraction, I was happy to read that you found it enjoyable. DW enjoys the show while I loathe it. So alas, I'm sure I'll find myself in the theater; your posts make me more comfortable with what I'll see. :mickey:

Oh - and GREAT JOB with the videos! Thank you for that! :thumbsup:

[CaptainJessicaSparrow]

A gentlemen made to be a randy clone, a paula type clone (both had different names) and a dude named simon (right) who was from the UK. Shocker.


As others have said, he was an AC CM before, as Otis or Hathaway (the performers changed roles at times). He really is a Brit and yes, his name is really Simon. I was talking to him before AC closed about it. He wasn't too thrilled about going to AIE. Like all equity performers, he is contracted because of his talents. He is a singer, as well as an actor. Since he is actually a professional, I think he is qualified to be a judge for amateurs.

[DizneyRox]

Sounds like another attraction I'll be skipping at the studios. Not a fan of AI and the review (while I understand it's testing) kindof confirms things.

[Diznee4Me]

Thanks for the review but having never watched the show - just not interested - it is probably something we will skip also.

[Nascfan]

I'm not a fan of the show, never really watched it except a couple of those audition ones with the bad singers, so I was not looking forward to this attraction.

I may be in the minority however, that John's review may have changed my mind. It sounds like something we may go into and check out if the line isn't too long, especially in the heat of a June day.
And no, it's definitely not Disney's answer to Harry Potter. That kind of comparison isn't even apples to oranges, more like steak to bread.

Thanks John! :thumbsup:

[DixieBelle]

Although I am not a fan of AI
I will still go and check it out.
Thanks for the review. :)

[BMan62]

Nothing about AI appeals to me or DW, BUT if her DS and BIL go with us I can guarantee we will be sitting through at least one show!!! (But, since that's well over a year away, I'm not putting much stock in seeing it!)

[4ubie1]

Thanks for the review on this attraction. :thumbsup: I was interested in seeing how they would handle this concept. Unfortunately, I am not a big fan of the program...something about public humiliation is not my bag. Granted, the contestants know what they are getting into but still...are we not encouraging it by watching. I have been hoping for years that this would be the last year for that show.:shake: I guess some dreams don't come true at WDW. ;)

Anywho..I still don't plan to attend this attraction even with so generous review...Sorry!:(

[Crow]

thanks for the review
I will be there in APril and I will make a point not to see it......i was forced to watch the show a few times by the ex( for those who remember i met her at WDW) and thats still something I hold against her
too much else to see there.
such a shame that Adventurers CLub performers had to end up there

[Darbylew]

I am not a fan so I am not excited about it. I
have never seen the show. I will probably check
in out when we are there in March. :mickey:

[Magic Smiles]

Not sure whether or not I would visit AIE, but I am wondering............how will the contestants handle the "Simon" critiques?

[CaptSmee]

John,
How do you audition for this? We are going to be there in May and my daughter and her husband would love to try to get on!!!
Luanne

There were cast members all around the entranceway as you walk into the park last week when I was there asking people if they wanted to audition. The actual area is in the back of the theater across from Sci-Fi Diner.

[CaptSmee]

John, we too caught a sneak preview last week at one of the closing shows. It was much better than we anticipated and everyone in our party enjoyed it very much, mostly because of the production of the show and the performers that were on stage. I did not care for the judge clones, coming up with new personalities would have been more fun for me.

On a side note, the show we saw they did make an announcement saying that this was in preview mode or test phase something along those lines and that not all performers had necessarily been through the audition process and that at this time it could have WDW performers as part of the show.

[Lightning McQueen]

Will the auditions only be performing Disney songs, or just pop music songs in general?

[Camping Mom]

My son got to participate in one of the "trial runs." No, it isn't all Disney songs. He had a ball going thru the process.

[Mickey 101]

We got to catch one of the preview shows recently, as well. We really enjoyed it. We were able to walk in as it was seating, so timing was such that we didn't see what happened in the queue or pre-show. We had been offered to audition, as well, but didn't take advantage of that, to the mercy of other guests. :blush:

We did not have 'Simon', but someone from the US who was essentially a clone of the one from the show. We weren't crazy about any of the judges. The host was Ryan Kim, and he did a very nice job. Two of our performers were definitely guests from the parks, but they really got into it. The third one, who was the best, was likely a CM, as she was from Orlando and they did a little more back-story info on her. All-in-all, I think it's a great addition to the park and it was a lot of fun.

[rookie]

Sounds like they need to recruit the two old guys from the muppet theatre for judges...either that or the robots from MST3000

[gwfx1031]

We caught a preview on Monday. I do watch the show, but was leary of how this would work at DHS. After seeing it, I really enjoyed the show. The production values were top notch. The show moved at a nice pace and took no more than 30 minutes once you are inside. There was a comedian that warmed up the crowd for a bit and he was a riot. I was dissapointed that he was not our host. The host we had was OK, but did not add to any of the excitement of the show. I agree with previous posts that the judges are too much like clones of the originals, but I assume that is the safe way to go for the majority. I would deffinately see this one again on future visits.

[Jasper]

We also saw one of the preview shows a couple of weeks ago and even though I am not an Idol fan I did find it to be fairly enjoyable. Later that same day I was hanging out near the Sci-Fi Diner waiting for the rest of our party to regroup and had the chance to talk to a Cast Member who is some kind of manager for the Idol attraction. I don't remember his name but it was something that sounded like Andy was spelled in some way that I have never seen before and would never have pronounced as Andy.

Anyway, between what he said and what I saw of the process I think that the "Producer" will have a big impact on the quality of each show. While these "producers" are characters within the scope of the show they do actually have real job duties deciding what show to put a candidate in and in what order they should perform. If the "producer" puts a couple of weak singers back to back or put a couple of ballad singers together in a row the show will likely suffer. Time will tell how good they get at their job and how well people turn out to sing in their show.

[cgriff]

Harry Potter world is coming to Universal, and this is the best they could compete with?

:offtopic:

It's more like H. Potterland is coming to Universal in an attempt to try and compete with WDW, not the other way around. The onus is on Universal.

Besides, how are they going to make it overcast and snow every day in central Florida?

I'm looking forward to trying the American Idol Experience this summer. I need to figure out what song I am going to sing tho, Hmmmmm...

[cgriff]

Sounds like they need to recruit the two old guys from the muppet theatre for judges...

That would be funny. Or how about a trio of Disney villains? Jafar, Hades, and the Cruella DeVille?

[BMan62]

Sounds like they need to recruit the two old guys from the muppet theatre for judges...either that or the robots from MST3000

Statler and Waldorf would be fun to watch and interact with. Crow T. Robot and Tom Servo would only be good if they had Mike to play off! (Actually, I liked Joel better as the foil for the robots.)