Olivia's vs. Whispering Canyon opinions please?!?!?!

[Disneyatic]

I was looking at menus and came across Olivia's at Old Key West....
The menu looks really good and we are trying to explore more resort restaurants this trip.
I was thinking of exchanging Whispering Canyon for this.
Any opinions on Olivia's? How is the atmosphere?? Would you recommend it?
Should we try both restaurants and just figure out a way to squeeze them in???

[Auntie]

I I would try to fit Olivia's in for a breakfast or lunch...that is what we are planning to do. I have a Whispering Canyon reservation and wouldn't switch it for Olivia's. I'd squeeze it in elsewhere. I have heard good things about it..and look forward to trying it..but have no plans to drop an ADR at Whispering Canyon.:mickey:

[Maleficent's Dad]

I love them both, but they are very different!

WCC is loud and bbq style with "hearty meals." The servers really are boisterous.

Olivia's is laid back with comfort food.

Love them both, but they are sooooo very different! :mickey:

[Natazu]

We like Olivia's. The food is really good and the service is fast & friendly. We eat there about every other trip. It's one of our fall-back restaurants if we end up without an ADR or get short on DP credits. Great breakfast and lunch too.