Printable View
Which one would you choose?
50's Prime Time Cafe', Sci-Fi Dine In or Mama Melrose's?
We have eaten at both the Prime Time Cafe' and the Dine In and really like them both! But...we would also like to try some place new. So, if you had to pick one, which would it be?
I've eaten at all three and would pick Mama Melrose's.
Mama Melrose is my pick. We always wanted to badly to like Sci- Fi, but we find the food there just awful. We like the theme but the food disappoints.
We're trying 50's for the first time this trip, but Sci-Fi is a usual stop each vacation. However, Mama Melrose usually gets a 3-time repeat; once for lunch & twice for dinner (Fantasmic Dinner Package). I too would choose Mama Melrose! :mickey:
I'm going to buck the trend and suggest Prime Time. Sci-Fi is neat, but the food is fairly horrible (but good desserts) and we had a so-so meal at Mama Melrose's. PT is yummy, and can be a lot of fun.
I've also eaten at all three and would pick Mama Melrose. The food there is so yummy. 50's prime time would be my 2nd choice and I really only like sci-fi for the experience, not much for the food.
Mama Melrose! We've eaten at both 50's and Mama and prefer the latter. Although the food is good at both of those places, Mama wins partly because the antics at 50's gets rather old.
Hands down Sci-Fi. It is the first request from everyone in the family, mainly for ambiance.
Hands down I would go with Mama's. Have never had any issues with food or service there.
I would go with 50's. Great food and a lot of fun!
To go against everyone that suggested Mama Malrose's, I would avoid it. we have only eaten there once and our server was aweful and the food was mediocre at best. I guess it could have been an off day, but because there are so many places at WDW to eat I think it will be a long while before we try it again. JMO
:thumbsup:Mama get my vote. Found the waitresses a bit too "motherly " for my taste at Primetime.
We have eaten at Mama Melrose and 50's Prime time. We enjoyed Mama Melrose, but not so much the 50's. Food not that good and not a lot of time to enjoy. Felt really rushed. Just my opinion °O°
We've eaten at all 3 and I would vote for Sci-Fi. The theming is so cool and if you go at lunch and get a burger, you'll be fine. I must add, though, that we enjoyed our meals at the other restaurants, also.