Tutta Italia or Mama Melrose's

[disneymom2000]

We are headed to DHS in the morning. I have an ADR at Tutta Italia for lunch which means leaving DHS and going to EPCOT for lunch and then going back to DHS for the rest of the day. I thought I might change my reservation to Mama Melrose's instead so I could stay in the park. Would you change your plans for convenience or break the day up? I haven't eaten at either of these establishments before.:confused:

[ANG]

I've only ever eaten at MM's, but really enjoyed it. We're going back again this year.

[RedSoxFan]

Mama Melrose is a great restaurant. We've eaten 3x and will again this next visit in December. I wouldn't leave DHS to eat in Epcot and then go back to DHS. I have never eaten at Tutto Italia; but it does look good and we are trying it in December too.

[VWL Mom]

We happen to enjoy both. Personally I would stay at DHS and go to Mama Melrose and continue with your day rather than go back and forth.

[phlo8810]

They are both good. Leaving the park is not really a big deal since they're so close. Having eaten at both my choice would be via Napoli to try something new.

[phillydan]

I've been to both & both are good. Tutto Italia would be my preference - a far better meal, IMHO. I guess the convenience would be a big part of the decision. Good luck!

[AllDisney]

I'd stay at DHS. You won't be disappointed. We love Mama Melrose's:thumbsup:

[disneymom2000]

Well, thanks for all the advice. It didn't matter because there are no openings for Mama Melrose afterall. This must be a pretty good place. I will remember it for next time.