tony's town square or liberty tree tavern

[disneypk]

wondering which is better tony's town square or liberty tree tavern. Never been to either one.

[afowl1017]

I must say I would choose Liberty Tree Tavern. However I am a little biased...ate there on my honeymoon for the first time, worked there when I was a CP, and I just love the pilgrim's feast! I have tried Tony's but had a bad experience with a really rude waiter and I didn't really think the food was amazing or anything ( I like Olive garden much better).

[It'sWDW4me]

I've never been to Tony's but DS and I love LTT - we've been there twice.

[ibelieveindisneymagic]

We've been to both, and without the characters at LTT it is a real toss-up.

We had good experiences at both, good service and decent food. The food isn't awesome at either, so I would decide which meal you would prefer, italian or thanksgiving dinner.

Either way, you'll enjoy it.

[renecat]

L.T.T. for sure ate at Tonys and also had a rude server. Thought it was not worth the money we paid.

[Seasonscraps]

For lunch I would go to LTT.

For dinner I would go to Tonys.

[NJGIRL]

We eat lunch at the Liberty Tree at least once every visit to Disney and love it. Tony's is the only place in Disney in all of our visits that I can say we had a truely bad meal. Sauce tasted like Ragu, pasta was way overcooked and it was overpriced for what we had.

[readytogo2]

after our last two meals at LTT i would go to Tonys. our meat was dried out ,terrible service and our mac and cheese tasted like Stouffers frozen-MMM. plus all our meals at Tonys have been very good and has a nice atmosphere

[japhilli]

We ate at LTT twice last week and it was WONDERFUL. We also ate at Tony's and it was okay...will most likely not go back there. The food was not that great and our waiter was rude and rushed us thru our meal...on the other hand our waitress at LTT (we had the same one both times) was great and the food was delicious.

[MississippiDisneyFreak]

We did not like Tony's, if I had to choose I would say LTT. We thought LTT was good but not great, any chance you could eat at one of the nearby resorts instead?

[Mom2princesses]

We had dinner at Tony's in June and we had a very good meal. No complaints at all our waiter was nice as well! I would not go to LTT for dinner without the characters.

I agree with one poster if you want Thanksgiving go to LTT if you want Italian go to Tony's.

Enjoy!

[AllDisney]

They are both OK. Nothing to write home about.

[LandFan]

They are both OK. Nothing to write home about.

I agree. Now that the characters are gone from LTT, I wouldn't pay the $$ or use the TS credit for a meal at either one. I would take the monorail to Chef Mickey's, Kona or O'hana first!

[SuzieN]

I like The Plaza better than either of those 2! Crystal Palace buffet is excellent also!!:mickey:

[PlutoPlanet]

We tried Tony's once and we vowed never again. The food was too bland.

[fmahan]

Liberty Tree Tavern has great food and characters stop by often while you are eating! Tony's food was just "OK" and the selection is so-so.:mickey:

[SBETigg]

after our last two meals at LTT i would go to Tonys. our meat was dried out ,terrible service and our mac and cheese tasted like Stouffers frozen-MMM. plus all our meals at Tonys have been very good and has a nice atmosphere

The mac n cheese at LTT is Stouffers. It's a Stouffers-sponsored venue. I would skip both, do counter service in the MK, and have a good meal at a nearby resort later or another time. Grand Floridian Cafe, 'Ohana, or Kona are all far better than Tony's and LTT, Narcoossee's and California Grill incredibly better if you don't mind spending more.

[ibelieveindisneymagic]

Liberty Tree Tavern has great food and characters stop by often while you are eating! Tony's food was just "OK" and the selection is so-so.:mickey:


LTT no longer has characters :( We really enjoyed the character interaction, and haven't been back since they left.