Tony's or Mama's?

[Miss Tink 2]

Trying to decide which Italian restaurant to choose-Tony's Town Square or Mama Melorose's? Have been to Mama's twice and really liked it, but have not been to Tony's-:confused:

[Natazu]

Between the two, I have to go with Mama's. The flatbreads are quite good and they have a more eclectic and traditional appetizer list.

In all honesty, they're pretty much both canned Italian food and present the usual "I'm stuck in a theme park" board of fare. The only truly great Italian place at Disney is at The Swan and isn't on the dining plan, but you'll love the place or I'll eat my next Disney meal at Sci-Fi.