Ice Cream - What's your favorite?

[Flower]

Stan's poll made me realize we have not had an ice cream thread in quite some time, and since summer is right around the corner I cannot think of a more perfect time to discuss
What is your favorite ice cream flavor??!!:D

An old fav is Ben and Jerry's Half Baked & Chunky Monkey....but anything chocolate or mint chocolate chip will do just fine!

[ElenitaB]

Coffee! And I discovered last night that Coldstone's coffee is not terribly coffee-ish. Dish me up some B&J's (the one with the Heath bars) or Haagen Daz (even the yogurt or the light one), please. :eat:

[conorsmom2000]

See, this is another one that's hard to answer because it totally depends on my mood. Chocolate is my most favorite, but if I really want to indulge, it's Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie (not the yogurt one!!). Chocolate Chip mint is another favorite.

And so many more!! :mickey:

[joanna71985]

Ohhh, ice cream! I love ice cream. My favorites are cookies and cream, fudge ripple, cookie dough, and just discovered Moose Tracks. Yum!!:D

[MaryPoppinsFan]

My all time favorite is Haggan Daz Chocolate Chocolate Chip. Brings back memories of my honeymoon at Disney. we stayed at the Holiday Inn which is now the Nick hotel I think and one day in the pouring rain we walked to the 7-11 and bought a pint, came back to the hotel and eat it sitting on the bed listening to the rain adn talking about our future. for the past 16 years it's been our anniversary gift to each other. still talking about our future :) :)

[MNNHFLTX]

It's Haagen Daz Rum Raisin--no contest! I got hooked on it when I lived with some roommates in a house right next to a Haagen Daz shop in south Minneapolis. We were very good neighbors to that shop. :tasty: :D

[DisneyFreak23]

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
no questions asked....:D

[SgtTigger]

Baskin Robbins Rocky Road...............


Nothing better...............:tasty:







:cop: :tigger:

[disneydeb]

Baskin and Robbins Pralines and Cream:thumbsup::thumbsup:

[PirateLover]

Breyer's Vanilla Bean
Haagan Daaz Strawberry
Almost any kind of Mint Chocolate Chip
Vanilla/Chocolate Swirl Soft Serve

[PAYROLL PRINCESS]

B&J's New York Fudge Chunk, Choco Chip Cookie dough, Peppermint stick.

[trennedy]

I love the cinnamon ice cream from Coldstone...It's wonderful!:thumbsup:

[RAIDER]

Rum and Raisin is my all time favourite :thumbsup:

[DisneyorBust]

A Mickey Ice Cream Bar!:bar: Enjoyed in the Magic Kingdom, of course!:D

[princessjojo]

Baskin and Robbins Pralines and Cream:thumbsup::thumbsup:
This is one of my f avorites, too! But too bad for me, the Baskin-Robbins shop near us closed and the Hershey Ice Cream shop opened insead.

One of my other favorites is homemade ice cream with Southern Butter Pecan coffee creamer used instead of all milk or cream. It is sooooo good, and adds some kick to the plain vanilla.

[jrkcr]

My DH has been eating Chunky Monkey for years, and I thought I didn't like it...until he went out of town for a week and left a new carton in the freezer. I ate the whole thing. I LOVE it!
:monkey:

[TheMartellFamily]

B&J Phish Food. YUM! I also like Bryers real vanilla bean ice cream.

[Kairi_7378]

Ben and Jerry's coffee heath bar crunch.
Ben and Jerry's chocolate chip cookie dough.
Last summer, I made a Kahlua chocolate chip ice cream that was pretty good, too!

[brertosh]

Gotta be Mint Chocolate Chip!

[BostonChic]

Pistachio for best flavor :thumbsup:
Haggen Daas for best brand :thumbsup:

[Ed]

Other than the obvious :bar: :bar: :bar: , Blue Bunny Peanut Butter Panic! :thumbsup:

:eat:

[RedSoxFan]

Chocolate is my favorite. I'm not a huge ice cream fan. My other favorite is Ben & Jerry's Gerry Garcia.

[Flower]

:offtopic: :twocents: I was ticked that WDW is no longer selling the Toll House Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich :mad: I was SO looking forward to one during our past trip

[Marker]

Vanilla. Call me boring, but I like vanilla. Sure, I'll eat other flavors, but vanilla is the one I always come back too.

[wdwgrl377]

I love Blue Bell Chocolate Chip, but they don't sell it here in NC, that I know of. I sure do miss that ice cream.

I do like Breyer's Natural Vanilla, with chocolate syrup, and I like Chocolate Almond, from Baskin Robbins!! :D

[quest4dl]

We have a wonderful mom and pop ice cream shop in the burbs of Chicago called Capanari's. They make the most delicious ice cream I have ever tasted. For commercial brands I like Haagen Daz - current favourite flavour is Caramelized Pear and Toasted Pecan. :thumbsup:

[Jeff G]

Ben & Jerry's Phish Food:number1:

(Brett, thanks for mentioning Baskin Robbin's Rocky Road. That's a close 2nd and I already have a plan laid out for tonight to got have ice cream with the family)

[laprana]

My absolute all time favorite is Baskin Robins Mint Chocolate Chip! A close second is Edys Rocky Road with the whole mini marshmallows! :tasty:

[Dakota Rose]

Mudpie Mojo at Coldstone Creamery

or

Chocolate Macadamia Nut at Lappert's

or

good old fashioned chocolate from the grocery store.

[Shugoondola]

I'm not too adventurous, but my favorites are vanilla and chocolate. Favorite brand is Blue Bell.

:mickey:

[Tink&Goofy]

Chocolate....doesn't matter what brand, or what is mixed in it (but an extra bonus for something chocolate mixed in :blush:. Chocolate....why waste the calories on any other flavor???

[The Reservoir Dog]

Mmmmmm Ice Cream!!!!

As someone else mention it depends on mood but my faves include Mint Choc, Cookies & Cream, that Cherry Garcia one and good old plain Chocolate flavour.

However at a friends house once he served up some Lemon ice cream and it was absolutely delicious.:)

[MissStyles]

has anyone seen the foodnetwork special "scoop" that aired a couple years ago? the winning flavor sticky toffee pudding is amazing. it's put out by haagen dazs. it's AWESOME! sunday i tried one of the runner up flavors...toasted coconut sesame brittle and it's also fantastic. haagen dazs is such a sin :thedolls: i only allow myself a few spoonfuls at a time.....but i love it just the same!

i love ice cream - i eat it nearly every single day. it's my one treat that i can't live without! :cloud9:

[Dracula766]

I agree with Emily. Haagen Dazs Sticky Toffee Pudding is the best!

The Coconut Pineapple is pretty good too. I had to steal my mom's pint.:D

[SBETigg]

Northampton MA's Herrell's Malted Vanilla with smooshed in Chocolate Malt Balls.

But close: Haagen Dazs Vanilla, Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia, Ben & Jerry's Chunky Monkey, and Ben & Jerry's White Russian topped them all but it was discontinued.

[BelleLovesTheBeast]

Cinnamoo from Maggie Moo's
Cherry Garcia from Ben and Jerry's

but my absolute favorite is Jamoca from Baskin Robbins. Has been for years.

[mjstaceyuofm]

My wife got an ice cream maker about 5 years back and I'm quite surprised at how much we use it. From her machine, I have a few faves:

1) Strawberry
2) Bailey's Irish Cream

But by far, my favorite is plain old CHOCOLATE from Krogers (Private Selection is the brand) with a heaping spoonful of JIF peanut butter slathered on top.

Yum. :tasty:

[scottgr]

YUMMMM ICE CREAM....
Cold Stone ---- Coffee and snickers...
YUMMM:thumbsup:

[Jared]

I firmly believe Haagen-Dazs makes the best ice cream in the world, even better than most homemade places, especially coffee and chocolate chocolate chip.

:tasty:

[ljv1975]

I love mint chocolate chip - I would like it even more if I could find some that was only the mint with NO chips!

Ben & Jerry's - Creme Brulee and Half Baked

During the Holidays, they make the peppermint kind which I also enjoy.

I can't pick just one!! :blush:

[Stitchahula]

my favorites are from an ice cream stand my dad used to inspect when he was a health inspector. Actually I have 2 favorites there
Kaluha crunch
malted moo crunch

they are only open during the warm weather so I have to wait until spring to get them. We just took my now 5 year old and my 9 month old there to play mini golf and get some really great ice cream. Oh the name is Kimballs

[Gooftroop5]

My fav is twist (chocolate/vanilla) soft ice cream. My second fav is Ben & jerry's everything but....

[Chrisx2]

Coldstone Creamery- Cake Batter Ice Cream or Chocolate Cake Batter.

Baskin Robbins Mint Chocolate Chip

And the Cookies and Cream Ice Cream sandwiches at WDW!

[Dracula766]

Coldstone Creamery- Cake Batter Ice Cream or Chocolate Cake Batter.

Baskin Robbins Mint Chocolate Chip

And the Cookies and Cream Ice Cream sandwiches at WDW!

ooh ooh ooh

the 2 best ways to have the cake batter ice cream is the Candyland (w/Snickers, M&Ms, Kit Kat) and the Birthday Cake Remix (w/sprinkles, a brownie and fudge). :party:

[Marilyn Michetti]

Dryers, (it's Ebys back East) Vanilla Bean.

The Contemporary has it in a soft serve, by the ounce, and it's AWESOME!:eat:

[EllieMae]

My classic faves is Blue Bell cookies and cream, but I have just recently discovered the Mediterranian Sea Salt gelatto at the Pacuigo place near me and I love it!! :number1: It is a perfect mix of caramel flavor and savory salt, may sound weird but its great!

[IloveDisney71]

If I'm at Disney I have to get a Mickey Ice Cream Bar or a Nestle Tollhouse Ice Cream Sandwich.
If I'm in the "real" world, my favorite flavor is cheesecake with real strawberries mixed in (from Marble Slab).:D

[Magic Smiles]

A good French Vanilla, with a sprinkled coated cone.

[jennbunn]

blue bunny birthday cake or ben and jerry's postachio. i also love dairy queens choco dipped cones. :cloud9:

[elmjimmlm]

Right now I am on Weight Watchers trying to lose before our trip so my favorite is WW big fudge pop...:thumbsup: