Need Contemporary advice! Atrium club, unsure of view,or non club Theme park view?

[mouseketeer mom]

The Atrium club does not guarantee a Theme Park view. Thats what we have booked right now. We are staying for the first time in November.
For those in the know..which would be a better Contemporary experience..(its our first time there!)..Atrium club without a guarenteed view, or no club, Theme park view.
Help!

[TammiMcMan]

Well, you do have a 50/50 chance of an MK view if you're staying on the Atrium floor. If you end up with something overlooking Bay Lake, I think you could possibly end up with the best of both worlds. From your room balcony, you can watch the Electric Water Parade and from the private lounge balcony, you can watch Wishes.

I guess your answer depends on how much time you're planning on spending in your room, looking at the view.

[murphy1]

I would really want that view!