Poll: Best 3D Experince

[lightyearfan]

For us it would be A Bugs Life, this has it all from a very well done theater that has things happening all around you to the biggest crowd reaction threw out the show

Victor

[mdricks]

Philharmagic, hands down.

[Hayden's Dad]

We love Muppets, can't wait to see them again in two days!!! Although Philharmagc is a really close second.

[Pastcastmemberdaughter]

Philharmagic is a great show, had to vote for that one!

[mook3y]

I really like all of them, but Philharmagic had the major "WOW" factor the first time I saw it.

Mickey :mickey: Magic.

Got to love it

[c&d]

I went with Philharmagic. I love the way the screen opens up to surround you.

Bug's Life a really close second.

[Pop Centurion]

I went with Philharmagic. I love the way the screen opens up to surround you.

Bug's Life a really close second.Same here.

[4ubie1]

I actually enjoy all but HISTA. It was fun when it was new but it has been showing it's age lately. I think a refurb would do nicely for this attraction. The rest I absolutely love especially Philharmagic :thumbsup:

[bratmaster]

sorry, but nothing even comes CLOSE to philarmagic! It was our entire family's favorite attraction between all 4 parks!

[January-2007]

Muppet Vision 3D. Love it. :mickey:

[Rosanne]

:mickey: I can't think of anything more perfect than Philharmagic. It makes me laugh and cry everytime I see it. Plus, the technology is top notch.

A close second is Muppet Vision. While the 3D technology is seriously sub-par, it is seriously the funniest show in WDW. :)

[Rosanne]

Also, might I say, this poll is a very good example of why Disney MUST do something about Honey I Shrunk the Audience. It just doesn't have the same affect that it used to have.

[indytraveler]

Bugs Life slightly better than Philharmagic. Like the bugs under your seats.

[Mickey91]

I voted Mickey's Philharmagic closely followed by Muppets, then HISTA, and I don't like bugs.

[TIdoubleGR]

Philharmagic all the way. One of my favorite attractions, period.:thumbsup:

[caryrae]

1) bugs

2) Phil (very very close second)

3) muppets

4) HISTA (just not the same anymore)

I like the waiting area for the bugs movies the best too.

[Damon18]

As much as I love the Muppets, I think that Philharmagic is the better show.:mickey:

[disneymom2000]

Bugs is tops. It is too hilarious.:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:

[GrmGrninGost]

I love them all, but, if I have to pick one it would be Muppet Vision 3-D!:mickey: It is sooo funny!!

[dumbo ears]

michey's philiharmagic is the best 3-d show I have ever seen in my life!

[DisneyPrincess01]

I really love all othe the shows but my favorite is Mickey's Philharmagic. It is so exciting and enchanting and it makes me feel like a little kid again. It is one of my favorite attractions of all time!

[Crow]

Muppets. though it could probably use an update
also like Philharmagic
then Bugs

[WDWfeelslikehome]

Mickey for us all the way!:mickey:

[maizey05]

Philharmagic and Bug's Life. Love the "be our guest" sequence of Phil. When DH went on Bug's the first time, he screamed like a little girl when the bugs were under his buns!
Don't like Muppet's and HISTA.

[WDWizard]

My vote goes for the obvious Mickey's PhillharMagic. It has great effects, and great scenes from different Disney movies which makes it great. It's Tough to be a Bug is very good too, but PhillharMagic beats this one out because of all the scenes from different Disney movies. Funny how nobody has really chosen Honey, I shrunk the audience. Of all the 3D shows, I think this is the one that needs the most updating, MuppetVision 3D is fun too, but it's starting to get old.

[Sean Riley Taylor's Mom]

Mickey's Philharmagic!! :mickey:

[Donald Duck 224]

I like them all, but it is philarmagic hands down. Great show.

[CU Tiger]

Philharmagic!! I can still smell the apple pie!:tasty: :mickey:

[Mariaºoº]

Also, might I say, this poll is a very good example of why Disney MUST do something about Honey I Shrunk the Audience. It just doesn't have the same affect that it used to have.

I totally agree!

[Mariaºoº]

Mickey's Philharmagic wins hands down for us! A Bug's Life a close second.

Should Soarin be in this poll? If so, then that would be right there with Philharmagic for me!

[MsMin]

ditto on the comments on HISTA.. maybe Wayne didn't shrink the audience-- by the looks of this poll-- nobody's there.

[LoriMistress]

That was a tough one. Though, I did pick Mickey's Philarmagic because I believe it's extremely well done--plus, it has my favorite man, Donald Duck.

Though, I love Muppets 3D. It's wonderful, hilarous, well themed, and a great production. That would be a close second.

[Darbylew]

Mickey's PhilharMagic is our favorite. Tough to
be a Bug would be our next favorite. :D
BEEN THERE, DONE THAT AND GOING BACK ON
MAY 29! :joy: :clappy:

[Vanlandingham]

Sure Mickey's PhilharMagic is the best by far from a 3-D perspective, but in terms of overall experience I've got to give it up for my beloved MuppetVision.

Though I do find it odd/slightly humorous that after 66 votes not one person has cast theirs in favor of HISTA.

[BritCody]

I like them all, but for me it has to be PhilharMagic

[LIGHTNING MC-DAD]

Philharmagic!! But we do love Muppets and Bugs Life.

[big blue and hairy]

Although since it's older, the 3-D isn't as good, I absolutely love the Muppets. It is very well done, and great Henson humor.

:sulley:

[keacc]

The quality on HISTK is horrible. Muppets is cute but needs to be updated. Bugs life is decent and so is PhilharMagic. Unfortunately, none of the Disney 3D can hold a candle to SHREK 4D at Universal. With all of the thousands of people working for Disney, they should not allow someone else to surpass them.

[ktflisa]

Don't tell my buddy Kermit, but I chose Bugs. DH and I sing songs from it all the time... But I do love the Muppets show too!

[T-Belle]

Philharmagic for me. I'm from the old "The Wonderful World of Disney" every Sunday night, and while I love all things Disney, the traditional :mickey2: :minnie2: :goofy2: :peter: :smickey: :tink: :donald: characters have a special place in my heart.

[RAIDER]

Mickeys Philharmagic (MK) .... without a doubt:mickey:

[TTA Metroliner]

I picked It's Tough to be a Bug becasue I like the fact that there are things going on all around you the whole time (even under your seat!!).

Philharmagic is a close second though!!

[darthmacho]

Bugs Life, since I haven't seen Philharmagic. :mickey:

Wow, HISTA hasn't got a single vote, you think it's outdated?

Even Muppets 3D, fairly popular because of the comedy, is getting kind of old.

[battle beast]

I love the Muppets! They win, hands down. :thumbsup: However, I do LIke DONALDS Philharmagic.

(I can't understand why the call it Mickey's Philharmagic when Donald is the main character.):confused:

[bobpfef]

Muppets! I wish they would do more with the Muppet characters.

[magicman]

This was a slam dunk for me...PhilHarmagic.

I'm not too surprised Honey, I Shrunk The Audience has drawn zero votes. I think it's time to upgrade the attraction.

[JPL]

The main problem is each show is an advance in Technology. I voted PhilharMagic since the effects are the best right now. Content wise is a toss up betweem ITTBAB and Muppets :thumbsup:

[MincaMouse]

Can I vote for Captain EO? I can't believe they replaced such greatness with the tripe that is there now.

[Figgyluv03]

Muppets!:kermit: I must have went everyday on my day off and always had to sit in the front row.

[SurferStitch]

1) bugs

2) Phil (very very close second)

3) muppets

4) HISTA (just not the same anymore)

I like the waiting area for the bugs movies the best too.

:ditto:

We love Philharmagic, but ITTBAB just seems to have a little more fun factor.

The only thing that is very disappointing with Phil is the poor image quality in the beginning and end where they are in the orchestra...it's very blurry. I know ITTBAB isn't the sharpest picture, but Phil has been like this from the very first time we saw it when it first opened.

[MrPeetrie]

This is one of my favorite attractions in all of WDW. Maybe it's the tremendous theming and queue area. Maybe it's the witty posters during pre-show. Or maybe it's because it's based on one of my favorite Disney movies. For whatever it is, this one is my favorite 3D movies by a narrow margin. (A Very Narrow Margin.):blush:

However, if the question was "what's my LEAST favorite." That's HISTA by a WIDE

Margin.:ack:

[KAJUNKING]

We love Muppets, can't wait to see them again in two days!!! Although Philharmagc is a really close second.

what he said, but in the other order :mickey: :confused:

[Polynesian Dweller]

Add another vote for Philharmagic with Muppets the next best for the fun factor. HISTA is getting a little old though in its time it was good.

[2Epcot]

The main problem is each show is an advance in Technology. I voted PhilharMagic since the effects are the best right now. :thumbsup:

I agree, since Captain E-O, every 3D show is an improvement over the next. As much as I love
Mickey's Philharmagic, I gave the slight edge to It's Tough To Be A Bug, for the overall presentation.

[DizNee143]

this was a toughy for me...i went with muppets...but philharmagic..is an extremely close 2nd!!!...:thumbsup:

[Rodders]

I love the Muppets! They win, hands down. :thumbsup: However, I do LIke DONALDS Philharmagic.

(I can't understand why the call it Mickey's Philharmagic when Donald is the main character.):confused:

Isn't that the running Joke with Mickey and Donald like the Mickey Mouse Club theme

M.I.C....K.E.Y..... M.O.U.S.E

Mickey Mouse.................. !Donald Duck!
Mickey Mouse.................. !Donald Duck!

etc etc.

Mickey gets all the credit whilst Donald has to work hard just to get a mention.

[Rodders]

Can I just say...

How dare you make me decide between some of my favourite attractions ;)

To make me pick a fave out of Muppets and Phil is just cruel :thumbsup: It's like choosing a favourite child.

[SillyOldBear]

is so the best one. Maybe its all the scary stuff in bugs and HISTA, but I don't really watch the whole thing (and then my husband gets mad when I sorda stand up at the end of Bugs). and the muppets is a little cheesy with the little 3-d guy.

[denygold]

Philharmagic is a must see for us !

[Jeff G]

Muppet Vision has such great detail and is so witty. IF you just walk in and watch the show it's good but study the details and it it's so much more.


PhillarMagic is a close 2nd.

[jrpersinger]

I can't really choose between PhilarMagic and Its tough to be a Bug. I love them both. They were both top picks for me. Same for my DH. Now our girls, they would say PhilarMagic hands down. Bugs kinda freaked them out. They were good till the bugs ran under the seats and the spiders dropped from the ceilings. LOL

[Simba'sBud]

Without a doubt, Mickey's Philharmagic for me! :number1: It's Tough to Be a Bug would be a very distant second. Nice thread.

[DakotaDisney]

PhilarMagic is the best over all show! Amazing 4D Show!!

Muppets is the second best over all and the best pre-show and the funniest show.

Bug's Life is a close second and the best audience surprises. I love to go and just watch people's reactions.

[Mrs.Mickey]

It has to be the muppets. i gotta thing for the swedish chef what can I say! Although Philharmagic is amazing as well! :mickey:

[LandFan]

Philharmagic is definitely the best 3D show I've ever seen! Not that I don't like the rest, but this one is amazing!!